En Fr
*Non technical* weblog about the IT world and its trends...
« Why features don't matter any moreThe Long Tail »

Efficient vs. effective

09/22/05

English (US) Efficient vs. effective

Guy 1: I am so efficient I can fold 100 parachutes in a hour.

Guy 2: I am so effective I can fold 100 parachutes and every single one of them will open right.

Would you rather give your parachutes to the efficient or to the effective guy?

Now what I'd like to know is why all these programmers we interview pride themselves on being efficient?
I'm so sick of their industrial strength bug generating skills... >:-[

8 comments

Comment from: Thierry [Visitor]
ThierryThe guy who accepts to jump in the parachute he has just folded is the effective guy.
09/24/05 @ 17:26
Comment from: Francois Planque [Member] Email
Well, trust me, too many guys think they've done it right as long as it doesn't fail... they may only realize after 50 jumps they have been doing it wrong all along.

Sadly enough, when it comes to programming, the cost of failure doesn't impact as much on the indivual as it does in skydiving... Yeah yeah okay I am JUST KIDDING! :)
09/27/05 @ 14:47
Comment from: Kochise [Visitor]
KochiseHmmm, if a skydiver crash, it costs, say, 1.000.000 euros to the insurance.

I used to work for the automotive industry. If a coder made a mistake, say, in the dashboard which control the speed regulation, that leads to a crash, 2 died consumers, several injuried people, many broken cars, and all cars from the same brand have to return back to the manufacturer for fix. Do you think it cost less than a lone lazy folder skydiver ?

Better be careful when you code in some places. Really...

Kochise
09/28/05 @ 09:26
Comment from: Francois Planque [Member] Email
Still... the guys who made the mistake doesn't die himself... at most, he might get a blame along with the other guys in QA...
09/28/05 @ 13:00
Comment from: Kochise [Visitor]
KochiseStill, from your own example, you compare skydivers with coders' "industrial strength bug generating skills". So in general the coder cannot die from his own code, only generate accidents... The skydiver could fold somebody else's parachute as well...

But if he is the driver of the car or one of the astronaut of Challenger ?

Kochise
09/30/05 @ 11:15
Comment from: Karen [Visitor]
Karenand if it takes a month for the effective guy to fold the parachutes, they'd be out of business.

a healthy blend of both attributes is required...
11/25/08 @ 19:35
Comment from: Jay Martin [Visitor]
Jay MartinThis reminds me of the old verbage, "don't confuse motion with progress".
08/04/09 @ 14:01
Comment from: Anis [Visitor]
Anis"The skydiver could fold somebody else's parachute as well...

Still if he falls over somebody else walking, he would cause death to others too as the coding guy. LOL

Conclusion we better be effectivly effecient.
11/13/09 @ 21:01

This post has 2 feedbacks awaiting moderation...

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)